Mar forgot to tell PNoy about BOI request

Police Director Benjamin Magalong, BOI-PNP head.

Police Director Benjamin Magalong, BOI-PNP head.

Interior Secretary Mar Roxas forgot to tell President Aquino of the request Police Director Benjamin Magalong to interview him before the Board of Inquiry on the Mamasapaano tragedy released their report last March 13, ABS-CBN reported.
Mar Roxas. Photo from KickerDaily.

Mar Roxas. Photo from KickerDaily.

Magalong said he met with Aquino in Malacañang on Tuesday together with Roxas and Philippine National Police Officer-in-Charge Leonardo Espina.

He said Roxas also apologized for failing to inform the President about the BOI’s request to interview him regarding the Mamasapano mission.

“Binanggit din niya syempre yung issue na bakit hindi ko siya na-interview. At in-explain ko rin sa kanya na, inamin din naman ni Secretary [Roxas] na talagang sa dami ng trabaho nakalimutan na mabanggit kay Presidente at dapat na-remind ko sila,” he said.

It will be recalled that Presidential Spokesperson scored the BOI for not getting the side of the President before issuing the report.

It was reported here Monday that Magalong asked Roxas last March 9 to relay their request to Aquino for an interview.

Following is the report of ABS-CBN’s Jeff Canoy:

“President Aquino was hurt by the findings of the Philippine National Police Board of Inquiry on the Mamasapano incident, according to the BOI chairman who was summoned to Malacanang to meet with the President.
Police Director Benjamin Magalong, chairman of the BOI and head of the Criminal Investigation and Detection Group, said he met with President Aquino in Malacanang on Tuesday, just days after the PNP released the full BOI report on the Mamasapano incident.

Present during the meeting were Interior and Local Government Secretary Mar Roxas, Justice Secretary Leila de Lima and PNP Officer-in-Charge Leonardo Espina.

According to Magalong, the President was hurt by the BOI findings.

“Visibly nasaktan siya. President siya. Nasaktan siya sa naging report, makikita naman yun. Pero even then during that time talagang very calm siya, talagang cordial at maayos naman ang aming discussion,” he said.

The BOI report earlier said the chain of command of the PNP was violated after the President, suspended PNP chief Alan Purisima and Special Action Force commander Getulio Napenas deliberately failed to inform the PNP OIC about the Mamasapano mission by keeping the information to themselves.

It also said the President “gave the go-signal and allowed the execution of Oplan: Exodus after the concept of operations was presented to him by…Napenas.”

It said the President allowed Purisima to participate in the planning and execution of Oplan Exodus despite the latter’s suspension.

It also said the President exercised his prerogative to deal directly with Napenas instead of Espina. The report said the act of dealing with Napenas instead of PNP OIC Espina “bypassed the established PNP Chain of Command.”

Magalong said the President explained that he gave instructions to Purisima to coordinate the Mamasapano mission with PNP OIC Espina. This order was not followed.

He said the President also admitted that he expected full cooperation between the SAF and military forces in Mamasapano, not knowing that Napenas did not follow his order.

Magalong described the meeting as “no holds barred,” with all contentious issues discussed.

“Sa mga contentious issues na nabanggit ng Presidente, binanggit ko rin kay Presidente na we never mentioned that you violated the Chain of Command. We just said that you exercised your prerogative to talk directly to Gen. Napenas. Andun sa conclusion namin. Kung anong conclusion namin is statement of fact. That is a statement of fact,” he said.

Magalong said Secretary Roxas also apologized for failing to inform the President about the BOI’s request to interview him regarding the Mamasapano mission.

“Binanggit din niya syempre yung issue na bakit hindi ko siya na-interview. At in-explain ko rin sa kanya na, inamin din naman ni Secretary [Roxas] na talagang sa dami ng trabaho nakalimutan na mabanggit kay Presidente at dapat na-remind ko sila,” he said.

The BOI chairman said he regrets failing to interview President Aquino before issuing the final BOI report.
However, he also admitted that the results of the BOI investigation will not be changed much.

For now, Magalong said he is focused on going back to work as CIDG chief after finishing what he describes as the hardest investigation in his career.

“I’m glad it’s over. It’s time to move on, there are so many thing need to be done,” he said.

BOI requested for interview with Aquino

It is not true that the Board of Inquiry did not try to get the side of President Aquino on the Jan. 25 Mamasapano tragedy that claimed 68 lives including 44 of the country’s elite police commandos, 18 members of the Moro Islamic Liberation Front, and six civilians, including an eight-year old girl.

DILG Secretary Mar Roxas accepts from PNP Board of Inquiry Chairman PDir Benjamin Magalong the copies of the report on the Mamasapano clash during the official turnover on Friday, March 13, 2015.

DILG Secretary Mar Roxas accepts from PNP Board of Inquiry Chairman PDir Benjamin Magalong the copies of the report on the Mamasapano clash during the official turnover on Friday, March 13, 2015.

Last March 9, BOI head Police Director Benjamin Magalong told the Interior Secretary Mar Roxas that they would like to interview the President and the latter promised to relay the request to Aquino.

This took place when Magalong requested Roxas for an extension to submit the report.

Magalong never got a notification from Roxas on Malacañang’s reply to his request. He submitted the BOI report last Friday.

Malacañang is not happy with the report of the BOI that investigated the Jan. 25 Mamasapano tragedy of which found that the Chain of Command in the Philippine National Police was violated and one of the culprits was President Aquino.

“The President, the suspended CPNP Purisima and the former Director SAF Napeñas kept the information to themselves and deliberately failed to inform the OIC PNP and the SILG. The Chain of Command should be observed in running mission operations,” the report said.

The other items in the Report’s Executive Summary focusing on the President’s role in the tragedy that claimed 68 lives including 44 of the country’s elite police commandos, 18 members of the Moro Islamic Liberation Front, and six civilians, state: “1. The President gave the go-signal and allowed the execution of Oplan Exodus after the concept of operations (CONOPS) was presented to him by Director of Special Action Force (SAF) Police Director Getulio Napeñas.

“2. The President allowed the participation of the suspended Chief Philippine National Police (CPNP) Police Director General Alan Purisima in the planning and execution of the Oplan Exodus despite the suspension order of the Ombudsman.

“3. The President exercised his prerogative to deal directly with Napeñas instead of Officer-in-Charge of the PNP (OIC-PNP) Police Deputy Director General Leonardo Espina. While the President has the prerogative to deal directly with any of his subordinates, the act of dealing with Napeñas instead of OIC-PNP Espina bypassed the established PNP Chain of Command. Under the Manual for PNP Fundamental Doctrine , the Chain of Command runs upward and downward. Such Manual requires the commander to discharge his responsibilities through a Chain of Command.”

Presidential Spokesman Edwin Lacierda

Presidential Spokesman Edwin Lacierda

Lacierda slammed the BOI report saying it “ introduced innuendos and resorted to speculations.”

He disagreed with BOI’s stand on the applicability of the chain-of-command doctrine saying the PNP is a civilian institution under the Executive Branch of government. “The President, as Chief Executive, exercises full and absolute control and supervision over every official in that branch,” he said.

Lacierda faults the BOI for not getting Aquino’s side. “The BOI in its efforts could have asked the President to clarify matters. The President would have answered any questions they may have had. But no official request was made. Instead, it introduced innuendos and resorted to speculations to reach some of its conclusions. This is all the more unfortunate because the head of the BOI, together with other senior officials of the Philippine National Police (PNP) was present in a meeting with the President where Police Director Benjamin Magalong had the opportunity to ask the President questions or seek further clarifications. As head of Criminal Investigation and Detection Group (CIDG), Police Director Magalong should be particularly aware of the need for due process to be observed.”

Lacierda must be referring to the March 4 meeting of the President with SAF officials at Bagong Diwa in Taguig City which focused on a review of the operations conducted to arrest the two terrorists who were the target of the Jan. 25 Oplan Exodus in order to improve future operations and other related concerns of SAF.

Is Lacierda serious about expecting Magalong to disrespect the President and do an ambush interview with him in the midst of a meeting with top PNP officials?

Lacierda, confirming the President’s complete control of Oplan Exodus, which he himself narrated in his meeting with religious leaders last Monday, said, “The President therefore left nothing to chance. His direct orders to Purisima if obeyed, would have ensured that the OIC Chief PNP would not have been kept in the dark. However, the President was disobeyed by Purisima.”

Lacierda said Aquino himself instructed the suspended Chief PNP, Alan Purisima to inform the OIC Chief PNP Leonardo Espina of Oplan Exodus.

Using Lacierda’s argument that Aquino is not covered by PNP’s doctrine of chain-of-command,because he “exercises full and absolute control and supervision over every official in that branch”, why didn’t he himself inform Espina? Why did he have to course it through Purisima, who had no business participating in PNP operations because of his suspension?

Aquino dealing with the suspended PNP chief all throughout the operations, as shown by text messages between the two, was an anomaly. He disrespected not only Espina but the whole PNP organization. Binastos ang PNP.

Magalong, by coursing his request for an interview with the President through the DILG secretary, showed respect for the Office of the President.Magalong was following protocol. He is with the PNP, which Roxas administers and controls as chairman of the National Police Commission.

The BOI never got a reply from Aquino nor from Roxas. Is Lacierda’s statement a case of story-telling-a lie which we had aplenty the past one and half months or a breakdown in communication in Malacañang?

Either way, it does not speak well of the current state of the Aquino presidency.

Ano ang nangyari kay Mar Roxas?

DILG Secretary Mar Roxas accepts from PNP Board of Inquiry Chairman PDir Benjamin Magalong the copies of the report on the Mamasapano clash during the official turnover on Friday, March 13, 2015. PNP-PIO photo.

DILG Secretary Mar Roxas accepts from PNP Board of Inquiry Chairman PDir Benjamin Magalong the copies of the report on the Mamasapano clash during the official turnover on Friday, March 13, 2015. PNP-PIO photo.

Sinabi ng Board of Marine Inquiry ng Philippine National Police na siyang nag-imbestiga sa trahedya sa Mamasapano, Maguindanao noong Enero 25 na nilabag ni Pangulong Aquino ang chain of command.

Dahil doon nagkandaloko-loko ang operasyon. Umabot 68 na buhay ang nalagas kasama na doon ang 44 na miyembro ng SAF, 18 na miyembro ng Moro Islamic Liberation Front at 6 na sibilyan.

Sa halip na purihin ang BOI sa pamumuno ni Police Director Benjamin Magalong, hepe ng Criminal Investigation and Detection Group, inabswelto pa rin ni Interior Secretary Mar Roxas si Pangulong Aquino.

Ito ang sabi ni Roxas: “Based on what I read, he (Aquino) as the commander in chief correctly and rightly authorized that (Zulkifli bin Hir) Marwan is a target. There is no liability with that. He gave the order to apprehend or to serve the warrant on Marwan and (Basit) Usman. Nothing wrong with that. Trabaho niya ‘yan. In fact, kung hindi niya ginawa ‘yan, may pananagutan ang Pangulo no’n.

“Since Purisima was coordinating directly with relieved Special Action Force commander Police Director Getulio Napeñas, Roxas said “it was up to them to do their jobs well.”

“The President recognized that Director General Purisima was suspended at wala nang kapangyarihan, alam ng Pangulo ‘yan. Kaya nga niya inutos, sabihin mo kay OIC Espina ito, precisely to correct the anomaly that there was somebody suspended in the middle. Eh hindi sinunod utos ng Pangulo eh.”

Tanga. Nag-aral ka pa sa Wharton, tapos hindi ka pala marunong umintindi ng report. English naman yun a.

Hindi madali ang ginawa nina Magalong. Ang kanilang ini-imbestiga ay mga taong may kapangyarihan sa kanilang posisyun. Ngunit nanindigan sila para sa katotohanan.

Tinumbok ng report ang may malaking panangutan sa trahedya: Si Pangulong Aquino, ang dating hepe ng PNP na si Alan Purisima, at si Napeñas.

Sabi ng BOI, binigay ni Aquino ang go signal ng Oplan Exodus sa pagtugis sa dalawang terorista na kanilang nalaman na doon nakatira sa Mamasapano, Maguindanao na teritoryo ng MILF at ang sumipak na Bangsamoro Islamic Freedom Fighters.

Nilabag ni Aquino ang regulasyon ng chain- of- command sa kanyang pakikipag-usap deretso kay Napeñas at initsa-pwera si PNP Acting Chief Leonardo Espina.

Nilabag din Purisima ang suspensyun sa kanya ng Ombudsman sa pagsali sa isang opisyal na operasyon.
Mali din ang pakipag-usap ni Aquino kay Purisima tungkol sa pagpapatupad ng Oplan Exodus dahil suspendido na ang kanyang paboritong hepe ng PNP.

Ito ang iilan lang sa report ng BOI. Pasalamat tayo kay Magalong na talagang nanindigan at nilabas kung anong totoo kahit na taliwas ang kanilang report sa palusot ng Malacañang.

Sa halip na suportahan ni Roxas, na siyang nagsu-supervise ng PNP bilang pinuno ng National Police Commission, pilit pa niyang pinapaikot ang pag-intindi ng report pabor kay Aquino

Kahit ano pang palusot ni Aquino at depensa ni Roxas, panagutan ito ng Pangulo. Siguro hindi ngayon habang sa Malacanang siya dahil hawak niya ang Kongreso. Kapag wala na siya sa Malacanang, malaki ang problema ni Aquino.

Kaya siguro todo depensa si Roxas akala niya mananalo siya kapag dikit siya kay Aquino sa 2016.

Hindi tanga ang taumbayan.

Ano ang nangyari kay Mar Roxas?

DILG Secretary Mar Roxas accepts from PNP Board of Inquiry Chairman PDir Benjamin Magalong the copies of the report on the Mamasapano clash during the official turnover on Friday, March 13, 2015. PNP-PIO photo.

DILG Secretary Mar Roxas accepts from PNP Board of Inquiry Chairman PDir Benjamin Magalong the copies of the report on the Mamasapano clash during the official turnover on Friday, March 13, 2015. PNP-PIO photo.

Sinabi ng Board of Marine Inquiry ng Philippine National Police na siyang nag-imbestiga sa trahedya sa Mamasapano, Maguindanao noong Enero 25 na nilabag ni Pangulong Aquino ang chain of command.

Dahil doon nagkandaloko-loko ang operasyon. Umabot 68 na buhay ang nalagas kasama na doon ang 44 na miyembro ng SAF, 18 na miyembro ng Moro Islamic Liberation Front at 6 na sibilyan.

Sa halip na purihin ang BOI sa pamumuno ni Police Director Benjamin Magalong, hepe ng Criminal Investigation and Detection Group, inabswelto pa rin ni Interior Secretary Mar Roxas si Pangulong Aquino.

Ito ang sabi ni Roxas: “Based on what I read, he (Aquino) as the commander in chief correctly and rightly authorized that (Zulkifli bin Hir) Marwan is a target. There is no liability with that. He gave the order to apprehend or to serve the warrant on Marwan and (Basit) Usman. Nothing wrong with that. Trabaho niya ‘yan. In fact, kung hindi niya ginawa ‘yan, may pananagutan ang Pangulo no’n.

“Since Purisima was coordinating directly with relieved Special Action Force commander Police Director Getulio Napeñas, Roxas said “it was up to them to do their jobs well.”

“The President recognized that Director General Purisima was suspended at wala nang kapangyarihan, alam ng Pangulo ‘yan. Kaya nga niya inutos, sabihin mo kay OIC Espina ito, precisely to correct the anomaly that there was somebody suspended in the middle. Eh hindi sinunod utos ng Pangulo eh.”

Tanga. Nag-aral ka pa sa Wharton, tapos hindi ka pala marunong umintindi ng report. English naman yun a.

Hindi madali ang ginawa nina Magalong. Ang kanilang ini-imbestiga ay mga taong may kapangyarihan sa kanilang posisyun. Ngunit nanindigan sila para sa katotohanan.

Tinumbok ng report ang may malaking panangutan sa trahedya: Si Pangulong Aquino, ang dating hepe ng PNP na si Alan Purisima, at si Napeñas.

Sabi ng BOI, binigay ni Aquino ang go signal ng Oplan Exodus sa pagtugis sa dalawang terorista na kanilang nalaman na doon nakatira sa Mamasapano, Maguindanao na teritoryo ng MILF at ang sumipak na Bangsamoro Islamic Freedom Fighters.

Nilabag ni Aquino ang regulasyon ng chain- of- command sa kanyang pakikipag-usap deretso kay Napeñas at initsa-pwera si PNP Acting Chief Leonardo Espina.

Nilabag din Purisima ang suspensyun sa kanya ng Ombudsman sa pagsali sa isang opisyal na operasyon.
Mali din ang pakipag-usap ni Aquino kay Purisima tungkol sa pagpapatupad ng Oplan Exodus dahil suspendido na ang kanyang paboritong hepe ng PNP.

Ito ang iilan lang sa report ng BOI. Pasalamat tayo kay Magalong na talagang nanindigan at nilabas kung anong totoo kahit na taliwas ang kanilang report sa palusot ng Malacañang.

Sa halip na suportahan ni Roxas, na siyang nagsu-supervise ng PNP bilang pinuno ng National Police Commission, pilit pa niyang pinapaikot ang pag-intindi ng report pabor kay Aquino

Kahit ano pang palusot ni Aquino at depensa ni Roxas, panagutan ito ng Pangulo. Siguro hindi ngayon habang sa Malacanang siya dahil hawak niya ang Kongreso. Kapag wala na siya sa Malacanang, malaki ang problema ni Aquino.

Kaya siguro todo depensa si Roxas akala niya mananalo siya kapag dikit siya kay Aquino sa 2016.

Hindi tanga ang taumbayan.

Mamasapano tragedy will be a factor in 2016 elections

Aquino meeting with families of SAF44. Feb. 18, 2015.

Aquino meeting with families of SAF44. Feb. 18, 2015.

Don’t expect the truth about the Jan. 25 Mamasapano tragedy to come from President Aquino.

He had one whole month to tell the Filipino people about his role in the debacle that claimed the lives of 44 members of the Special Action Force of the Philippine National Police, 18 members of the Moro Islamic Liberation Front and six civilians including an eight-year old girl who was hit in the crossfire.

He had three televised address on the armed operation that turned into a massacre – Jan. 28, three days after the tragedy; Jan. 30 necrological service at Camp Bagong Diwa, and Feb. 6 to announce his acceptance of the resignation of suspended Police Chief Alan Purisima.

The people, grieving and angry, wanted an explanation to give sense into the senselessness of brutal deaths of 44 of the country’s elite police officers who were on a mission to arrest two terrorists wanted by the U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation.

But Aquino’s monologue didn’t enlighten because he instead talked about the assassination of his father in 1983 and the 1989 coup against his mother.

Press Secretary Herminio Coloma said Aquino will decide to reveal what he knows about the police operation at the appropriate time: “Pagpapasyahan po niya ‘yan sa takdang panahon.”

Aquino can take his own sweet time about his version of the truth but the people will know what really happened in Mamasapano in one way or another because borrowing a quote from Chinese writer Lu Xun about the March 1926 massacre in China, “Lies written in ink can never disguise facts written in blood.”

Aquino’s problem with telling the truth about the Mamasapano debacle is because he would be implicating himself.

The line that the administration is trying lead the public to take is that the President was misled by Purisima of the real situation on the ground. They cite the text exchanges between Aquino and his trusted police officer, where the latter was the telling the President at 8:17 in the morning that the military has already sent reinforcement to the SAF: “They are presently in contact with reinforcing elements from BIFF. The containment forces are the ones in contact right now. They are supported by mechanized and artillery support sir.”

But the same text exchanges showed Aquino knew that Oplan Exodus had been operationalized as early as 5:28 in the morning. The text messages also revealed that Aquino was very much involved in the planning of the operation including the physical terrain and the number of personnel involved.
.
Aquino can’t escape accountability for giving Purisima, a suspended government official authority, to be involved in a highly sensitive security operation.

And if Purisima is the culprit,how come Aquino was all praises to him when he accepted the former’s resignation?

The reason why Aquino can’t find the “takdang panahon” to tell the truth was articulated by his sister, Kris Aquino, who said last Sunday, ““Let’s be honest, maraming magiging kaso next year (na isasampa laban sa Presidente.)”

Kris said that in answer to the question by actress Nora Aunor if she will run for an elective position in the 2016 elections. The presidential sister said, anticipating the lawsuits, she has to support her brother.
The Mamasapano tragedy will surely be a factor, in more ways than one, in the 2016 elections.

Aquino will have to make sure that his successor will be an ally or someone who will not do to him what he did to Gloria Arroyo and what Arroyo did to her predecessor, Joseph Estrada.
***

Justice Secretary Leila de Lima

Justice Secretary Leila de Lima

Speaking of lawsuits, Secretary Leila de Lima should not waste government resources on the National Transformation Council.

But she got it with her “Do not pervert a nation’s grief” statement issued last Sunday especially her description of the group: “religious and political has-beens.”

She said NTC’s call for people power is a “carefully formulated strategy in the false hope of propagating it legally in the mass media and among supporters without however accruing any criminal liability under the penal laws on rebellion, sedition, and coup d’ etat. This is a false hope, since certain actions already implemented by the group, from organizing foras and conferences of supporters and sympathizers, can already be contemplated as conspiracies relating to sedition, rebellion or coup d’ etat.”

Former Defense Secretary and NSA Adviser Norberto Gonzales had said in a TV interview that there is nothing wrong with people power, or a change in regime through people power which happened in EDSA 1 and 2.

De Lima said:“This is Gonzales’ doublespeak. The NTC has publicly declared in its meetings and so-called consultations that a people power strategy for regime change can only be successful if backed by military support for the installation of the National Transformation Council as a ‘transition government’, and the suspension of elections or any other democratic process sanctioned under a constitutional government, until the enactment of reforms to be dictated by the NTC as the de facto government of the Republic.

“Everything in this strategy is illegal and unconstitutional, except probably for the people power part if executed merely as a form of mass mobilization in the exercise of the people’s freedom of assembly. The installation of the NTC as the governing body of the Republic is nothing but the installation of a civilian-military junta, and the call for the military’s support for its defense and installation is nothing less than a proposal or conspiracy to commit the crime of coup d’etat. The NTC’s pronouncements and publicly declared strategy for the capture of state power through active military support to the NTC are therefore acts which already constitute conspiracy or proposal to commit rebellion and coup d’ etat (Art. 136 in relation to Arts. 134 and 134-A, Revised Penal Code), conspiracy to commit sedition (Art. 141 in relation to Art. 139, RPC) or, at the very least, inciting to sedition (Art. 142, RPC), as well as illegal assemblies (Art. 146, RPC).

“A junta by any other sanitized name is still illegal and unconstitutional. By calling for people power and military support to force the President’s ‘resignation’ in order to pave the way for a junta, the NTC and its mushrooming allied alphabet soup organizations of discredited government officials consisting of charged plunderers, grafters, and tax evaders, or of those under investigation for such crimes, may have just crossed the line of legitimate dissent. The government will not relent in applying the full force of the law against them in order to protect the people and the State from an unconstitutional and illegal power grab.

“In the end, any civilian or religious-led putsch will not succeed, because the military will never support the extra-constitutional installation of a junta led by GMA bishops and ex-officials. The AFP and the PNP stand behind the President, no matter how the Mamasapano incident is exploited by opportunists, such as NTC, to sow discord and division among their ranks. It is the height of pathetic gutter politics, when the tragic loss of 44 police officers killed in the line of duty is used by disgraced pathological personalities to crawl their way back to national relevance, at the expense of the people’s effort to come to terms with the complex issue of peace in Mindanao in their search for justice for the SAF44. The nation is still grieving, and without any sense of shame, these personalities would use the people’s grief to pervert a national catharsis, serving only their own thirst and craving for absolute power by imposing upon this nation a tyranny of religious and political has-beens.”