Journalists shot, attacked in Malawi, S Africa, Zambia

JOURNALISTS in Malawi, South Africa, and Zambia were beaten up, shot, and assaulted by security forces in separate incidents this past week, according a report by the Media Institute of Southern Africa (MISA).

A nongovernment organization focused on the promotion of free, independent and pluralistic media, freedom of expression, and media development. MISA runs programs for journalists and photojournalists in countries of Southern African. Its report follows:

In MALAWI:

On Thursday, 30 May 2013 Malawian photojournalist Thoko Chikondi was punched several times by the chief parliamentary security officer at the parliament building as she went about her duties, photographing a consumer rights advocate, John Kapito, who had just presented a petition to the national assembly.

However, the chief security officer, identified as Youngson Chilinda, accused her of taking pictures without permission. An image, which appears on the front page of today’s (31 May) The Daily Times shows Chilinda with his fist raised towards the visibly shaken female journalist while pulling her hair with the other hand.

As a result of the assault, the photojournalist sustained bruises on the back and was treated at Kamuzu Central hospital in the capital, Lilongwe. The matter has since been reported to Lingadzi Police Station.

Chilinda is a retired soldier and has previously expressed political aspirations, losing out on a parliamentary seat in the last election in 2009.

The Chairperson of the Malawi Chapter of the Media Institute of Southern Africa (MISA-Malawi) and also MISA Regional Governing Council Chairperson Anthony Kasunda has condemned the assault on the journalist.

“This is uncalled for and regrettable and a great shock to MISA. We strongly request Parliament to investigate and discipline Chilinda. Parliament is a public place and Chikondi had every right to freely gather and report on what was happening at Parliament. Such barbaric acts must stop,” Kasunda said.

At the time of publishing this alert, it was not clear if Chilinda would be arrested.

In SOUTH AFRICA

Photojournalist Motshwari Mofokeng was on Wednesday, 29 May 2013, wounded in the chest when a security guard shot a rubber bullet directly at him. According to the 30 May edition of The Star, the daily newspaper Mofokeng reports for, the incident occurred while he was “covering an eviction of illegal residents living in a building once used as a factory.”

In his own words, Mofokeng was quoted as saying: “I [was] shot in the chest, but (even) before that, I had been slapped twice. The guard had walked away from me as the pain intensified. We don’t know who he is, or what led to the incident. But I’m sure he’ll soon explain himself in a court of law.”

Just before he fell to his knees after being shot, Mofokeng managed to capture the image the security guard shooting directly at him. The image, along with an inset of Mofokeng’s chest wound, appeared on The Star (30 May) front page.

The Star editor, Makhudu Sefara has said his newspaper will “exhaust every possible avenue to ensure that the man who shot Motshwari face the full brunt of the law.”

He added: “Too many photographers have been beaten and even shot in the line of duty recently. Yesterday (Wednesday) they picked the wrong photographer and the wrong newspaper. We intend making an example here and now before one of our colleagues is killed.”

In ZAMBIA

On Saturday, 25 May 2013 Zambia Army personnel roughed up two photojournalists as they tried to capture pictures of dignitaries laying wreaths at the Freedom Statue as part of Zambia’s commemoration of Africa Day.

In an interview with MISA-Zambia, freelance photojournalist Jean Mandela Ndayesega and The Post newspapers photojournalist Salim Dawood, both confirmed being roughed up when they refused to vacate the advantageous position they had stationed themselves at to capture good pictures of the event.

“We tried to reason with them that we want to get good pictures of the event but they would not listen to us and instead roughed us up.” Dawood explained.

In an interview, Zambia Army Public Relations Officer, Colonel Chris Musonda, said that his institution was ready to dialogue with MISA to ensure a conducive media operating environment in Zambia. “We are there for the people and we will be sure to address such matters,” Col. Musonda said.

MISA-Zambia chairperson, Nalumino Nalumino expressed disappointment at the manner in which the two photojournalists were handled by army personnel.

“We wish to appeal to the Zambia Army to orient their officers on how to handle the media during public events because such incidents, if left unchecked, may lead to censorship on the part of the media and reduced access to information on the part of citizens who both the media and the army want to serve,” he said.

MISA Programme Specialist for Media Freedom Monitoring and Research, Levi Kabwato, has described the journalists who came under fire this past week as “brave”.

“They are all brave. The courage they displayed under fire is inspirational and for that we salute them. We are very relieved that none of them was seriously wounded or even lost their life,” Kabwato said.

“Our promise to them, and all the journalists we serve in this region, is that we will continue to work hard in ensuring that the operating environment is not hostile and that journalist’s rights are respected across SADC,” he said.

He added: “We also appeal to public officials and the wider public to familiarize themselves with the role of journalists in society. Some of these attacks wouldn’t occur if there was sufficient understanding of the critical role played by journalists. We further ask all media houses to ensure that their staff have access to medical cover and are equipped with tools and tactics that can enable them to prevent attacks when covering potentially dangerous beats.”

Ampatuan suspects plead not guilty to murder of 58th victim

by Cong B. Corrales

A QUEZON CITY COURT today arraigned 78 Maguindanao Massacre suspects for the murder of the 58th victim, but deferred the arraignment of suspected mastermind and clan patriarch Andal Ampatuan Sr.  and several others due to “pending unresolved motions.”

The 78 who were arraigned for the murder of Sultan Kudarat photojournalist Reynaldo “Bebot” Momay include former Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao Governor Zaldy Ampatuan, his brother Andal Jr, and 76 others. They all pleaded not guilty to the charge of murder.

Momay had not been included in the original list of murder victims because his body was never found. Under Philippine law, several years have to lapse before a missing person is declared legally dead.

The court however decided to defer the arraignment of Andal Sr., five other clan members, and seven other suspects for Momay’s murder because of several motions they had previously filed before the court.

National Union of Journalists of the Philippines chairperson Rowena Paraan, in an update emailed to media organizations, reported that Zaldy, Andal Jr., and the others who were arraigned had entered a not guilty plea. The Ampatuan trial is being held by the Quezon City Regional Trial Court Branch 221 at Camp Bagong Diwa in Taguig City.

“However, pending unresolved motions, the court deferred the arraignment of clan patriarch Andal Ampatuan Sr., five other clan members, and seven other suspects,” Paraan said. Andal Sr. and the other Maguindanao massacre suspects had earlier pleaded not guilty for the murders of 57 other massacre victims.

Paraan said there are 196 suspects in the Maguindanao massacre, considered the worst case of election violence in the Philippines, and the worst single case of media murders in the world. Of these suspects, only 106 have been arrested, and no one has been convicted in the four years since charges were filed.

It can be recalled that Momay was formally included as a victim eight months after the Department of Justice (DOJ) found probable cause to file a case on his behalf.

Although Momay’s body remains missing to this day, police Scene of the Crime Operatives (SOCO) found his dentures and a jacket–identified by his daughter Reynafe Momay-Castillo as his father’s — wrapped around the body of another victim at the crime scene in Sitio Masalay, Barangay Salman, Ampatuan town, Maguindanao province.

The Ampatuan massacre, which has led international media organizations to declare every 23rd of November as the International Day to End Impunity, claimed 58 individuals, 32 of whom were media workers. In its latest special report on Impunity Index, the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) has ranked the Philippines third worst in the world. Worse, the country ranked third for the fourth consecutive year.

“The insecurity of witnesses is a key problem in addressing impunity. Authorities in the Philippines, ranked third worst on CPJ’s index, have yet to make headway in the prosecution of dozens of suspects in a politically motivated massacre in Maguindanao province that claimed the lives of more than 50 people, including 32 journalists and media workers, in 2009. Three witnesses in the Maguindanao case have themselves been murdered, one of them dismembered and mutilated,” the report reads.

Never forget: The Ampatuan massacre

text and photos by
Cong B. Corrales

JOURNALISTS AND MEDIA WORKERS held a photo exhibit, ecumenical prayer and candle-lighting ceremony on Thursday (May 23) in New Manila, Quezon City to remember the victims of the grisly Ampatuan Massacre that shocked the world 42 months ago, and remind the nation of the continuing reign of the culture of impunity in the country.

The travelling exhibit dubbed “Never Forget: The Ampatuan Massacre” opened in the morning at the National Cathedral of St. Mary and St. John, 277 E. Rodriguez Sr. Avenue, Quezon City. This travelling exhibit includes photographs of Jes Aznar, Nonoy Espina, and Veejay Villafranca, Vincent Go, among others. The exhibit shows how the nation moves forward from the gruesome murder that exposes how impunity works at its worst. Never Forget has been displayed in schools, churches, and government institutions such as the Congress and Senate.

Media groups led by the National Union of Journalists of the Philippines (NUJP), as well as journalists from different media outfits, capped off the whole-day memorial with an ecumenical prayer, a short program and a candle-lighting for the victims of impunity.

In her speech during the program, Rowena Paraan, NUJP national chairperson said that while the media community continues to remember the the victims of the massacre, journalists and media workers across the nation should also fight against the continued culture of impunity under the Aquino administration.

“Why must PNoy wait for 2016? He must do what he can to stop this culture of impunity now,” said Paraan.

For her part, Edith Tiamzon—wife of Ampatuan Massacre victim Daniel, a UNTV cameraman—expressed her gratitude for the media community’s continued support.

“Kahit na parang hindi umuusad ang kaso, nagpapasalamat ako sa suporta ninyo. Nagbibigay ito ng lakas ng loob magpatuloy hanggang makamit natin ang hustiya,” Tiamzon told journalists and media workers.

Forty-two months ago, police and militiamen supposedly led by Andal Ampatuan Jr. waylaid a convoy that was supposed to file the candidacy papers of Esmael “Toto” Mangudadatu. The incident on November 23, 2009 led to the death of 58 people, including 32 journalists, and has since been known as the worst case of election-related violence in recent years. The massacre has also been known as the single most brazen attack against journalists and media workers.

The Ampatuan massacre has earned the country the dubious role of being the international poster cover of impunity. The International Freedom of Expression Exchange Network (IFEX)—a federation of 90 independent organizations worldwide—has declared every 23rd of November, as the International Day to End Impunity.

Forty-two months since the massacre, 99 of the 196 accused are still at large. Exacerbating this is the snail-paced trials brought about by 750 pleadings (motions, manifestations, petitions, comments) filed; 540 of which are filed by the defense panel. There are still 103 of the 307 motions filed by both the defense and prosecution have yet to be resolved by the Quezon City Regional Trial Court Branch 221. One of the witnesses have been killed and another one allegedly committed suicide.

In its latest special report on Impunity Index, the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) has ranked the Philippines third worst in the world. Worse, the country ranked third for the fourth consecutive year. War-torn Iraq and Somalia ranked first and second, respectively.

The country’s impunity index rating this year is “0.580 unsolved journalist murders per million inhabitants.” Last year, CPJ also ranked the Philippines third worst in the world with a rating of 0.589.

“Despite President Benigno Aquino III’s vow to reverse impunity in journalist murders, the Philippines ranked third worst worldwide for the fourth consecutive year. Fifty-five journalist murders have gone unsolved in the past decade,” the May 2, 2013 special report of CPJ entitled “Getting away with murder,” reads in part. The CPJ—founded in 1981—is an independent, non-profit organization that advocates for “press freedom worldwide by defending the rights of journalists to report the news without fear of reprisal.”

Published yearly, CPJ’s Impunity Index special report monitors “countries where journalists are killed regularly and governments fail to solve the crimes.” The 2013 Impunity Index report covers media killings which have remained unsolved from January 1, 2003 to December 31 last year. CPJ’s report this year lists 12 countries since they listed only countries with five or more unsolved cases. The group considers a case unsolved “when no convictions have been won.”

The CPJ report has identified the government’s inability to secure the witnesses of media killings as its foremost obstacle in ending the culture of impunity in the country.

“The insecurity of witnesses is a key problem in addressing impunity. Authorities in the Philippines, ranked third worst on CPJ’s index, have yet to make headway in the prosecution of dozens of suspects in a politically motivated massacre in Maguindanao province that claimed the lives of more than 50 people, including 32 journalists and media workers, in 2009. Three witnesses in the Maguindanao case have themselves been murdered, one of them dismembered and mutilated,” the report reads.

2 supporters of mayoralty bets shot dead, 1 hurt in N Samar

CATARMAN, Northern Samar — Two persons were killed and another was wounded in three separate shooting incidents in three towns of this province on Saturday and Sunday, eve of election day.

The first casualty, a former councilor of Barangay Libho, Catarman town, was shot dead at around 9 am, May 12, at a spot just a few kilometers away from the provincial headquarters of the Philippine National Police. The victim was identified as Arturo ‘Boy’ Gallano.

The second victim, a supporter of a Liberal Party candidate for mayor was held up and shot dead by armed men in San Roque town on Saturday, May 11. The suspects fled with a bag full of cash that the victim was carrying.

In a third incident in Gamay town, the supporter of a re-electionist mayoralty aspirant was shot in the stomach by armed men wearing bonnets flagged down the jeepney he was driving and shot him at close range on Saturday. He has been rushed to the hospital.

Police Officer 1 Kennel Tafalla, officer-on-case in the first incident, said that at around 9 am, a black Nissan car with plate No. NR 999 arrived in Barangay Libho. One of its passengers alighted and inquired about the location of the barangay hall.

The car motored on when a man riding a motorcycle chased it and demanded that the car passengers get off. The car passengers reportedly opened fire. Some of the shots hit and killed Gallano on the spot, the police said.

Witnesses described one of the suspects to be about 33 years old, with curly hair and tattoos all over his body. Three empty shells of a 9-millimeter pistol and one empty shell of a .45-caliber pistol were recovered from the crime scene.

The police tagged the case as an election-related incident because the victim was a political leader of Catarman mayoralty candidate Francisco Rosales, a former mayor of Catarman.

In the second incident in San Roque town, a campaign leader of Liberal Party mayoralty candidate Jocelyn Uy-Curso was reportedly held up and shot dead by armed men at around 3 pm on Saturday.

The San Roque poiice said Uy-Curso’s campaign leader, a certain Nestor “Entong” Surio, was riding a habal-habal motorcyle with five other passengers enroute to Barangay Pagasangjan.

Upon reaching Sto. Mukidbukid in Barangay Bantayan, several armed men wearing bonnets reportedly stopped the motorcycle, grabbed a bag full of cash, and shot Surio in the head. Witnesses said the suspects fled to different directions.

Meanwhile in Gamay town, re-electionist Mayor Timoteo Capaquian of reported that one of his supporters was also shot in the stomach by still unidentified armed men Saturday evening, May 11. The victim was rushed to Catarman Doctors’ Hospital.

A relative of the victim who requested not to be identified said that at around 9 pm, the victim was driving his jeepney on his way to a nearby barangay to ferry some passengers when several armed flagged down the vehicle and shot him at close range.

The suspects reportedly fled toward the direction of Lapinig town.

Mayor Capoquian called the case a election-related incident saying that he had received information earlier that his political opponent was planning to sow trouble.

Deadline Approaching: Basic Investigative Reporting Seminar

Basic IR web photo-large

PCIJ’s Basic Investigative Reporting Seminar: Political Clans, Governance, and Journalists’ Safety

Open to mid-career and senior Filipino journalists, citizen media, and bloggers
Researchers, anchors, producers, editors, news managers, freelance reporters, contributors, and stringers of print, TV, radio, and online media may apply. Citizen media and bloggers covering public policy issues are also eligible.

Application Deadlines and Tentative Seminar Dates:

Visayas
Application Deadline: May 17, 2013
Seminar Dates: June 27–30, 2013

Mindanao
Application Deadline: June 10, 2013
Seminar Dates: July 25–28, 2013

Luzon
Application Deadline: July 10, 2013
Seminar Dates: Aug. 22–25, 2013

NCR
Application Deadline Aug. 1, 2013
Seminar Dates: Sept. 19–22, 2013

Seminar Topics

Session 1: Media Killings, Political Violence, and the Culture of Impunity in the Philippines

Overview of media killings and human rights abuses in the Philippines; the hot spots of political violence and human rights abuse; The legal context, and international and Philippine protocols on Conflict, Human Rights, and Extra-Judicial Killings.

Panel Discussion with officials from government agencies involved in monitoring and prosecuting human rights and extra judicial killings cases such as the Philippine National Police, the Armed Forces of the Philippines, the Department of Justice, and the Commission on Human Rights

Session 2: Political Clans: Past and Future Links

Historical analysis of political clans and their networks in government; The connections between the rule of political clans in certain areas with development plans and the socio-economic conditions of the areas; Participation of certain political clans in the May 13, 2013 national and local elections and its implications for governance.

Session 3: The Government’s Purse: Tracking the State’s Resources

The government’s budget process, assessment of the use and spending of various lump-sum funds (e.g., PDAF, IRA), and the sources of financing available to national and local government agencies; Information and insights journalists may derive from datasets available on government websites.

Session 4: Ethics and Safety: Field and Newsroom Judgment Calls

Discussion of measures that newsrooms may implement to protect journalists, and ethical and editorial standards that media agencies may institutionalize; Practical safety tips and safe-passage techniques in high-risk and dangerous areas of coverage.

Session 5: The Fundamentals of Investigative Reporting

Investigative methods and tools that could be used when studying political clans, governance, and extra-judicial killings.

Session 6. Tracking the Investigative Trails

  • Practice Set A. The Paper Trail: Understanding, Connecting, and Organizing Documents and Databases — a “show-and-tell” session of the different types of documents useful for journalists doing in-depth reports on political clans and governance.
  • Practice Set B. The People Trail: The Art of the Interviewmock interviews and critique session

Session 7: Putting the Story Together

Various techniques to make a complicated and data-driven story accessible to citizens; How an investigative report can be translated for broadcast (TV and radio) or rendered on multimedia platforms.

Workshop: Pitching Story Ideas and Developing Story Plans

Funding

The PCIJ will cover:

  • Round-trip transportation from the participant’s place of work and/or residence to the seminar venue.
  • Board and lodging during the seminar.

The PCIJ will also provide a modest fellowship grant for story proposals that will be approved during or immediately after the seminar.

Application Requirements

  1. Completed application form with two references (see attached .doc file).
  2. One or two samples of work discussing public policy, development, human rights, or governance issues.
    • For print and online: link to the stories or attach copies of stories in Word or PDF
    • For TV and radio: link to the broadcast story, or attach script or story concept/treatment

Successful applicants will be notified within 10 working days after deadline.
The seminar graduates will be accorded priority slots in the subsequent Advanced Investigative Reporting Seminars that PCIJ will conduct in 2014.

Sending your application:

By email:
Email address: training@pcij.org
Please state ‘Application to Basic IR Seminar’ on the subject line

Note: We will acknowledge receipt of all submissions. If you do not receive any reply within three working days, please resend your application and move a follow-up email or call (02) 410-4768.

By fax:
Telefax: (02) 410-4768
Please write ‘ATTN: PCIJ Training Desk’ on the fax cover sheet

Note: After faxing, please call (02) 410-4768 to confirm if all the documents had been transmitted successfully.

By mail:

The Training Desk
Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism
3/F Criselda 2 Bldg., 107 Scout de Guia St.
Brgy. Sacred Heart, Quezon City 1104

Note: We will acknowledge receipt of mailed applications via email or text.

Questions?
Please contact the PCIJ Training Desk at (02) 410-4768 or training@pcij.org

Through combined onsite and field learning sessions, the seminar aims to enhance the participants’ investigative reporting skills and practice, and offer a framework for analyzing media killings and safety issues in the context of governance, the culture of impunity, and the presence of political clans and private armed groups in many parts of the country. The seminar also seeks to highlight the role of the police and the Commission on Human Rights as vital sources of journalists.

The seminar will feature lecture-discussions and workshops to identify potential risks and practical safety tips when covering dangerous assignments. A Story Development Workshop will give participants an opportunity to pitch story proposals that the PCIJ may consider for fellowship grants and editorial supervision.

Experts from the academe, national media organizations, the police, human rights agencies and organizations, and data repository agencies will lead the discussions.

This seminar series draws support from the US-based National Endowment for Democracy (NED).