ARMM: Stodgy, ill-starred stats

NO SAFE WATER and toilets in homes mostly not powered by electricity. Far fewer doctors and health facilities care for their babies and mothers. They die up to 10 years earlier than most Filipinos across the nation.

Yet still, the people of the Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (ARMM) have had to flee their homes incessantly on account of intermittent clashes between soldiers and armed groups.

ARMM, home to 3,256,140 Filipinos as of the 2010 census, is a stodgy record of ill-starred stats.

As of 2011, of the 455 waterless municipalities in the country, 94 are in the five provinces of ARMM, according to the Philippine Institute for Development Studies’ repot titled “Water Financing Programs in the Philippines: Are We Making Progress?”

These 94 waterless towns of ARMM come from the region’s five provinces — 36 in Lanao del Sur, 20 in Maguindanao, 16 in Sulu, 11 in Tawi-Tawi, and 11 in Basilan.

More detailed official data as of 2003 showed that 8 of 10 people in Tawi-Tawi, 7 of 10 in Basilan and Sulu, five of 10 in Maguindanao and 4 of 10 in Lanao del Sur did not have access to improved water sources.

The number of households with access to safe water supply as of 2007 revealed that of Marawi City’s 26,009 households, only 5,064 have access to safe water supply (19%), and only 13,400 or half the households have sanitary toilets.

Electricity also remains a scarce public good in ARMM. While 40 percent of Lanao del Sur’s population had power as of 2007, people located elsewhere in ARMM continue to linger in the dark, literally. Up to 63 percent of the people in Basilan; 76 percent in Maguindanao; and 83 percent in both Sulu and Tawi-Tawi, hade no electricity as of that year.

By another index, the number of rural health units or RHUs in the nation as of 2011, ARMM fares just as poorly. Of the 2,314 RHUs in the Philippines, only 119 are in ARMM – 42 in Lanao del Sur, 33 in Maguindanao, 19 in Sulu, 13 in Basilan, and 12 in Tawi-Tawi, according to the Department of Health.

The number of district and provincial hospitals in ARMM presents a picture just as lean and bad – the Philippines has 584 district hospitals and 89 provincial hospitals. However, the slice of the pie that goes to ARMM is a pithy 24 district hospitals and two provincial hospitals, or one each in Sulu and Tawi-Tawi. None exists as yet for the provinces of Maguindanao, Basilan, and Lanao del Sur.

In terms of the latest infant mortality rate data, the National Statistical Coordination Board reported that in the Philippines, an average 23 babies per 100,000 population die each year before reaching age 5 as of 2006. The figure for ARMM was much more at 33.

The proportion of children under a year old who had been immunized against measles stood at 81 percent across the nation in 2003. The ARMM figure is much lower at 76.9.

When mothers give birth, attendance and care by skilled health personnel would be most safe and ideal, In the Philippines as of 2006, seven in 10 or 70.1 percent of mothers giving birth got this service as of 2006. In ARMM, only 49.1 percent or less than five in 10 got the service.

But the sorriest number of all pertains to the life expectancy of men and women in ARMM. As of the latest 2000 data, across the nation, Filipino males live up to 66.11 years, and Filipino females, up to 71.64 years, according to the Philippine Statistical Authority.

In ARMM, Filipinos die five to 10 years younger, however. Life expectancy among males in the ARMM provinces is much, much shorter. In Maguindanao, life expectancy is at 60.3 years for males, and 61.65 for females; in Sulu, 56.97 and 58.53; in Tawi-Tawi, 56.13 and 57.5; in Lanao del Sur, 61.87 and 62.74; and in Basilan, 61.and 67.43.

As of the 2010 census, the National Statistics Office said ARMM’s 3.25-million population consists of 293,322 people in Basilan, 933,260 in Lanao del Sur,
944,718 in Maguindanao, 718,290 in Sulu, and 366,550 in Tawi-Tawi. – With research and reporting by fernando Cabigao Jr. and Jaileen F. Jimeno, PCIJ, March 2015

When politicians wed in style: Simple living, lavish partying

WHEN POLITICIANS WED, it almost always seems like they throw all caution to the wind and forget about how they are supposed to comport themselves as public officials. They should, according to the Constitution and the law, live by some principles, not least of them these two: Lead simple lives and avoid conflict of interest situations.

The upscale wedding of Sen. Francis Joseph G. Escudero and actress Heart Evangelista (baptized as Love Marie Ongpauco) on Feb. 15, 2015 was just the latest in a series of grand political unions.

Check out the Files of FRANCIS JOSEPH ‘CHIZ’ G. ESCUDERO on PCIJ’s MONEY POLITICS ONLINE:

Public Profiles
Campaign Finance
Public Funds

Escudero, of course, was not the first politician to have shown he is given to excess when it comes to marrying.

On Oct. 27, 2009, then Senator Manuel “Mar” Roxas II exchanged wedding vows with broadcast journalist Korina Sanchez at Santo Domingo Church in Quezon City. More than 10 bishops and priests officiated the ceremony attended by about 3,000 people, and before a crowd of spectators outside the church.

On Jan. 22, 2012, then Valenzuela City Councilor Shalani Soledad, one of the former girlfriends of President Aquino, tied the knot with Pasig City Representative Roman Romulo in glamor and style at St. Benedict Church in Sta. Rosa, Laguna. Some of those prominent and powerful from politics and business attended, too.

But at the Escudero-Evangelista nuptials, no less than President Benigno S. Aquino III was enrolled as best man, although pressing affairs of state prevented him from attending the ceremony. The two men have been chummy since their days as members both of the House of Representatives and the Senate.

For starters, the Escudero-Evangelista gig was held at the Balesin Island Club, an exclusive, members-only resort in Polillo, Quezon province. Alphaland Corp. developed the resort; its chairman and chief executive officer, Roberto V. Ongpin, also stood as one of the principal wedding sponsors.

Two lavish wedding receptions were held for the couple and their guests – the first on Balesin Island and the second, three days later, at the high-end Blue Leaf Filipinas in Aseana City in Parañaque City.

The groom and bride would not disclose how much they’ve spent on the wedding and the receptions. Escudero would only say that they spent only what they could afford.

Suggestions that the wedding had locked him in a conflict of interest situation on account of some sponsors from big corporate entities, Escudero had been quoted in an ABS-CBN news report as saying: “Tatayuan ko ano ang tingin kong tama at lalabanan ko ano ang tingin kong mali. Anumang conflict, ang importante dinedeklara iyon para kung ano man ang posisyon mo sa isang bagay, maliwanag at alam ng publiko (I will stand by what I think is right and fight what I think is wrong. What’s important is to declare any conflict so that whatever your position is on anything is clear to the public}.

Numerous sponsors were drafted into the wedding, because, Escudero explained, “siguro kasi sa larangan ng showbiz ang napangasawa ko kaya maraming sponsors kaugnay sa bagay na iyon (Maybe we had many sponsors because my wife is in showbiz).”

A lawyer by profession, it is unusual that Escudero seems to make light of the relevant provisions of the Constitution and the law.
Under Section 4 of Republic Act (R.A.) No. 6713 or the “Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards for Public Officials and Employees,” public officials and their families are supposed to live simply and modestly and “to not indulge in extravagant or ostentatious display of wealth in any form.”

Then, too, how Escudero managed to bankroll such a grand wedding is not clear. In his 2013 Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth or SALN, he declared a net worth of only P8.243 million, including = cash of only P3.183 million.

The roster of wedding sponsors are an evident trigger of a conflict of interest situation for Escudero. Such conflict, the law and jurisprudence say, could be either real, perceived, or potential.

Apart from Roberto V. Ongpin of Alphaland, the other sponsors who saw Escudero wed Evangelista were the other top guns of Philippine business — Ramon S. Ang of San Miguel Corp. a food-infrastructure conglomerate; Fernando Zobel de Ayala of the Ayala Group of Companies that is into retail, telecommunication, and real estate ventures; Lance Y. Gokongwei of JG Summit Holdings, a food-retail-property-retail-airline combine; Hans T. Sy of the SM Group of Companies, a property and mall developer; and Andrew L. Tan of the property developer Megaworld Corp. Then, too, the couple had sponsors from among the top executives of the television networks ABS-CBN, GMA-7, as well as Viva Entertainment Inc.

Indeed, while he had said that having many sponsors was largely on account of his wife’s job as an actress, the couple’s longer list of sponsors from business and politics seemed to have been hinged more on Escudero’s job as a politician.

From the world of politics, those who attended as wedding sponsors included Sen. Grace Poe; Adelbert W. Antonino, former mayor of General Santos City; lawyer Gilberto M. Duavit Sr., former representative of the first district of the province of Rizal; Faustino S. Dy Jr., former governor of the province of Isabela; and Esther E. Hamor, mayor of Casiguran town in Escudero’s home province of Sorsogon.

Some of the bills that Escudero has filed as a legislator offer clues to how he has engaged with some of these sponsors.

For instance, Escudero was the principal author in the senate of R.A. No. 9649, an act amending the charter of General Santos City, that was signed into law on July 7, 2009.

In August 2010, the local government of General Santos City had cited R.A. 9649 as a ground for the filing of administrative and criminal charges against the officials of the National Commission on Indigenous Peoples (NCIP) and the Register of Deeds for issuing an ancestral land title to the Bansalao-Banisil family of the B’laan tribe.

In a MindaNews report, former city Mayor Darlene Magnolia Antonino-Custodio, daughter of Adelbert Antonino, pointed out that under the amended city charter, proper consultations with the local government is needed before NCIP can issue a Certificate of Ancestral Land Title. (Like Escudero, Darlene Custodio had also served in the House of Representatives.)

For another, Escudero has also filed Senate Bill (S.B) No. 2104, which aims to amend Batas Pambansa Bilang 68 or the “Corporation Code of the Philippines” and allow a one-person corporation. Under the current law, at least five but not more than 15 persons are needed to form a private corporation.

Also as a senator, Escudero filed S.B. 2449, which seeks to amend the National Internal Revenue Code to lengthen the period for qualified VAT-registered individuals to apply for claims for refunds and tax credits.

Meanwhile, the Senate Blue Ribbon Committee is currently investigating a property deal between the Boy Scout of the Philippines (BSP) and property developer Alphaland Corp. whose chairman and CEO is Roberto V. Ongpin, an Escudero wedding sponsor.

The Senate had summoned Ongpin to explain the agreement between BSP and Alphaland on the development of the BSP’s one-hectare property in Makati City.

Then, too, two of Escudero’s wedding sponsors, Ramon S. Ang and Gilberto Duavit Sr., had also served as Escudero’s election campaign donors in 2007.

Ang, president and chief operating officer of San Miguel Corp., had donated P9 million to Escudero on his first run for the Senate in 2007. Duavit, a former politician and former chairman of the Republic Broadcasting System (now GMA Network, Inc.), gave Escudeor P1 million in campaign contribution, also in 2007. – Fernando Cabigao Jr., PCIJ, February 2015

EDSA: Timeline of a Revolt

A CIVILIAN-BACKED military uprising that toppled a dictator, the EDSA People Power Revolt of 1986 capped long years of a tug o’war between repression and resistance.

Born to a multitude of fathers and mothers who fought, died, and survived martial rule and dictatorship, EDSA to this day offers myriad lessons to all its children young and old.

Here in brief is a timeline of the EDSA backstory. PCIJ_EDSA revolt_FEB2015

PCIJ infographic by Cong B. Corrales

VIDEO: EDSA People Power Revolt

WE TAKE a look back at the EDSA People Power Revolt in this video short of images and interviews by the PCIJ of 20 people who took part in the campaign to remove former President Ferdinand E. Marcos. For the first episode of “Balik Tanaw,” let’s listen to former defense secretary, now Sen. Juan Ponce Enrile, human rights lawyer Rene A.V. Saguisag, singer-songwriter Jim Paredes, newspaper publisher Eugenia Apostol, and broadcast journalist Atom Araullo – all key players in the uprising that changed the course of history.

View the video on our YouTube Channel.

Click on the photo to read our articles.

SENATOR JUAN PONCE ENRILE, former defense chief of then President Ferdinand E.  Marcos | Photo by Lilen Uy

SENATOR JUAN PONCE ENRILE, former defense chief of then President Ferdinand E. Marcos | Photo by Lilen Uy